How to Host an Easy Afternoon Tea at Home
Sandwiches, scones and cake without the stress. What to serve, how much to make, the order to eat it in, and the jam-or-cream question.

Afternoon tea sounds grand, but at heart it is simply tea with something to eat, served with a little more ceremony than usual. You do not need a three-tier stand or a silver service. With some sandwiches, a batch of scones and a good cake, you can host an afternoon tea at home that feels special without spending the whole day in the kitchen.
What is served at a traditional afternoon tea?
A classic afternoon tea has three parts, usually eaten in this order:
- Savoury first: dainty finger sandwiches with the crusts cut off.
- Scones next: warm scones with jam and clotted cream.
- Sweet to finish: cakes, biscuits and small bakes.
Working from savoury to sweet means nobody fills up on cake before the sandwiches, and it gives the afternoon a gentle rhythm.
The sandwiches
Keep the fillings classic and simple. Cucumber with a little butter and black pepper, egg mayonnaise with cress, and cheese with ploughman’s pickle are reliable favourites. Use soft bread, cut off the crusts and slice into neat fingers or triangles. Make them no more than an hour or two ahead, and cover them with a slightly damp clean tea towel so they do not dry out.
The scones
Scones are best on the day they are made, ideally still slightly warm. If you are baking your own, a simple plain or fruit recipe is all you need. If time is short, a good bakery scone warmed in the oven for a few minutes does the job beautifully. Serve them with clotted cream and a generous pot of strawberry jam.
Jam or cream first?
Ah. The tradition usually credited to Cornwall is jam first, then cream on top. The tradition usually credited to Devon is cream first, then jam. Both have passionate supporters, and both taste wonderful. Our advice is to put both on the table, let your guests decide and avoid discussing it if you would like the afternoon to remain pleasant.
The sweet things
You do not need to bake everything yourself. A mix of homemade and ready-made is perfectly respectable. A slice of rich fruit cake is a traditional choice, and buttery shortbread is ideal for nibbling alongside a second cup. If you do want to bake one thing, make it a Victoria sponge, sandwiched with jam and dusted with icing sugar.
Which tea should you serve?
A strong, classic English Breakfast is the safe choice and pairs well with everything on the table. For something more fragrant, offer a pot of Earl Grey, which is lovely with lemon. It is a nice touch to offer one caffeine-free option too, such as a ginger and lemon infusion, for anyone who would rather avoid caffeine later in the day.
Warm the pot, use one bag per person plus one for the pot, and let it brew for four to five minutes. Keep a jug of hot water nearby for topping up.
How much food do you need?
As a rough guide, allow per person:
- Four to six finger sandwiches
- One or two scones
- Two or three small sweet items, such as a slice of cake and a biscuit
- At least three cups of tea (this is not a time for restraint)
Afternoon tea etiquette, without the fuss
There are plenty of rules if you go looking for them, but at home only a few matter. Pour the tea before adding milk if you are using a pot. Break scones in half by hand rather than cutting them. Stir your tea gently rather than clinking the spoon round the cup. Most importantly, make sure everyone’s cup is topped up and that nobody leaves hungry.
Setting the table
Mismatched china looks charming, so there is no need for a matching set. Add a jug of flowers, cloth napkins and a cake stand if you have one; if not, a few plates at different heights work just as well. Lay everything out before guests arrive so you can sit down and enjoy it too.
An easier way to start
Our Afternoon Tea Box brings together English Breakfast tea, shortbread, fruit cake and strawberry jam, so all you need to add is scones, cream and good company. Shop the range and order before 1pm on a weekday for same-day dispatch.